Implementing reforms, not just formulating them – The contribution of the Balanced Scorecard and the XPP process

2 March 2026
Article
mplementing Reforms, _Not Just Formulating Them The Contribution of the Balanced Scorecard _and the XPP Process

1. Introduction

What is the Balanced Scorecard method? ?

The Balanced Scorecard (BSC) is an integrated strategic framework that translates an organisation’s vision and priorities into concrete, measurable actions that are aligned at all levels.

Developed in the early 1990s by Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton of Harvard Business School, the BSC is now a global benchmark in strategic management and performance management.

The founders – Kaplan and Norton (Harvard Business School)

Kaplan and Norton demonstrated that 90% of strategies fail not because of how they are formulated, but because of poor execution.
Their method bridges this gap with a strategic framework based on four perspectives:

  • Stakeholders/Finance
  • Stakeholders/Finance
  • Internal processes
  • Learning and development

A widely adopted method, particularly in the public sector

Over 70% of the world’s largest companies and many governments use the BSC. It has been successfully adapted to:

Ensuring the achievement of results and the sustainability of benefits
Improve accountability and transparency
Strengthen inter-institutional coordination
Monitor public policies and development plans

Structure relationships with technical and financial partners

Examples of government adoption

United-States
US Army

Canada
Federal ministries

Rwanda
Ministry of Local Governance (Vision 2020)

United Arab Emirates
Public Innovation Strategy

Morocco
Ministries of Finance, Interior, Justice

An agile and adaptable approach

The BSC adapts to the realities of developing countries:

  • Gradual adoption through pilot projects
  • Compatible with Results-Based Management (RBM)
  • Rapid deployment (Excel, Power BI, etc.)
  • Strengthens governance through strategic reviews

Conclusion

The Balanced Scorecard is a common strategic language, a robust monitoring framework, a public transformation tool, and a results-oriented management philosophy.

“The Balanced Scorecard is not a reporting tool, it is a management and execution philosophy.” – R.S. Kaplan

2. Strategic benefits of the method for the organisation

Clear translation of national or sectoral strategy

  • Transformation of vision into measurable objectives via the BSC
  • Clear prioritisation of public interventions
  • Institutionalisation of a strategic management process (XPP)
  • Continuous cycle of planning, execution, review, learning
  • Integration of strategy into key management processes
  • Improved performance management
      • Monitoring of KPIs
      • Data-driven decisions

Organisational and cultural benefits

Strengthening internal capabilities

  • Creation of a permanent strategic hub (Office of Strategy Management)
  • Development of a culture of strategy
  • Enhanced collaboration between departments
  • Alignment of inter-institutional objectives
  • Implementation of strategic governance
  • Quarterly strategic reviews involving all stakeholders

Benefits for cooperation and national impact

Improved dialogue with partners/stakeholders:

  • Structured presentation of results
  • Easier alignment with stakeholders
  • Easier alignment with donors/Ministry of Finance

Alignment of projects with national priorities:

  • Effective management of the project portfolio
  • Impact on government performance in managing reforms
  • Improved consistency, accountability and resource mobilisation

Systemic impacts

Challenges Contributions of BSC/XPP
Project fragmentation Multi-stakeholder strategic alignment
Poor cross-sector coordination Centralised governance and shared implementation (deconcentration)
Lack of reliable data Consolidated dashboards
Volatility of plans Continuity through a permanent strategic hub
Low impact of investments Monitoring and evaluation of key initiatives with measurement (measurement method, targets, KPIs (key performance indicators), reporting standards, operational reviews and strategic reviews
Siloed execution of strategic initiatives, the main source of strategy/reform failures Establishment of a Strategy Management Office equipped with:

  • Strategy governance system
  • Strategy execution performance system
Lack of a “reference framework” and common management standards Institutionalisation of an agile strategic steering process (XPP):

  • Continuous cycle of planning, execution, review, learning
  • Integration of strategy into key management processes
  • Smooth communication using common concepts and vocabulary

Conclusion

Adopting the BSC method and the XPP process:

  • Positions the organisation as a key player in public transformation/reform
    • Provides a shared business vision for greater cohesion among strategic initiatives
    • Effective identification of strategic priorities
    • A single strategy with decentralised but coordinated execution
    • Effective collaboration to achieve common strategic objectives
  • Strengthens
    • Performance
    • Coordination
    • The impact of national development policies and strategic initiatives
    • Organisational alignment and capacity building on national and sectoral development strategies
  • Establishes a fundamental framework for
    • Strengthen Results-Based Management (RBM)
    • Develop a performance culture
    • Measurement-based accountability
    • Continuity of transformations and reforms (preservation of plans in the event of organisational changes)

If this topic resonates with you, explore our seminar Mastering Strategic Initiatives and Organisational Change below.

Salahdine Ourzik

An article by Salahdine Ourzik, MBA, PMP, BSC/XPP, LMI

Strategic planning
Organisational Change Management
Leadership Development
Corporate Performance System
Rédigé par
Salahdine OURZIK
Salahdine OURZIK
MBA, PMP, BSC/XPP, LMI